Washington, D.C. — The U.S. Department of Labor has advanced a regulatory proposal that significantly complicates independent contractor classifications for the trucking industry. Published as a 184-page Notice of Proposed Rulemaking in the Federal Register, the updated framework seeks to replace a Trump-era standard established in January 2021 under the Fair Labor Standards Act. This regulatory shift alters how motor carriers evaluate CDL-A driver and owner-operator partnerships, moving away from a system centered primarily on worker control and profit-and-loss potential.

Under the previous standard, enforcement hinged largely on two core factors: the individual's opportunity for profit or loss and the degree of control exerted over the work. The newly proposed rule introduces four additional metrics, bringing the total to six, and requires equal weighting across all of them. This holistic approach strips away the previous emphasis on actual practice over theoretical possibility, making it substantially harder for trucking companies to justify independent contractor statuses for drivers hauling freight.

Despite the broader criteria, federal officials acknowledged within the rulemaking document that the agency lacks the statutory authority to enforce a strict ABC test. Widely adopted by various state labor agencies, the ABC test mandates that independent operators remain free from hiring entity control, perform work outside the core scope of the carrier's standard business operations, and maintain an independently established trade or business. The second requirement presents an insurmountable barrier for traditional motor carriers partnering with independent owner-operators, as freight hauling constitutes the direct core of their business operations. Legal experts confirm that adopting an ABC test nationwide would require explicit congressional amendments to the Fair Labor Standards Act or a complete reversal of existing judicial precedent by the Supreme Court.

What This Means for Drivers

For independent owner-operators and fleet managers, this regulatory push threatens long-standing business models across the sector. Transportation attorneys note that the proposed criteria penalize motor carriers for enforcing standard safety protocols and regulatory compliance measures. Because federal and state FMCSA regulations mandate carrier oversight of equipment maintenance and hours of service, the new DOL standard forces carriers into a difficult position where compliance itself can be weaponized as evidence of employee misclassification. Owner-operators who value their independence and business autonomy face heightened administrative scrutiny as trucking companies review their operating agreements to mitigate legal exposure.

Industry Reaction

Legal analysts and motor carrier representatives have pushed back against the Department of Labor's expansive view of control in a heavily regulated environment. Transportation attorney Greg Feary pointed out that past judicial rulings consistently held that requiring compliance with federal safety laws, highway rules, and client delivery specifications did not constitute employer control. The current rulemaking proposal rejects that longstanding precedent, asserting that all instances of behavioral oversight must factor into classification decisions. In a sector where compliance with safety mandates is non-negotiable, treating regulatory adherence as proof of employment creates severe operational friction for trucking companies hiring independent talent.

Key Points

• The Department of Labor released a 184-page Notice of Proposed Rulemaking to overhaul independent contractor guidelines under the Fair Labor Standards Act.
• The updated framework balances six distinct evaluation factors instead of prioritizing worker control and profit-and-loss opportunities.
• Federal regulators confirmed they lack the legal jurisdiction to enforce a strict ABC test without congressional action or Supreme Court intervention.
• Transportation attorneys warn that factoring safety compliance and regulatory adherence into worker classification conflicts with established judicial precedent.

Looking for a better trucking job? US Trucker's free job-matching service connects CDL-A drivers, OTR drivers, regional drivers, and owner-operators with 500+ top US carriers. Leave your details in the form on this page and a recruiter will call you within one business day. Trucking companies are hiring now.

Photo by Brendan Rühli on Pexels